Share authentic Italian hospitality with your team, cast, or guests. Every catering order is prepared fresh to order at 744 9th Ave—featuring daily extruded fresh pasta, Alfredo Di Lelio’s 1900s Trilogy, Polpette della Nonna, crisp Bruschette, and Sicilian Cannoli.
Every group has different tastes and dietary needs. Select a format below as a starting point—our kitchen will prepare a custom quote based on the exact dishes you choose.
Alfredo Di Lelio’s early 1900s Rome recipe: fresh handmade egg fettuccine spun with sweet cream butter and 24-month Parmigiano Reggiano. Available in Original, Roman Style, or Truffle Way.
✓ Vegetarian • GF Pasta Substitution AvailableAuthentic Roman emulsions crafted with bronze-die pasta, aged Pecorino Romano DOP, toasted black pepper, and crispy guanciale.
✓ 0% Heavy Cream • GF Pasta Substitution AvailableChoose from Tagliatelle alla Bolognese, Rigatoni alla Vodka, or seasonal market pasta creations extruded fresh in-house.
✓ GF Pasta Substitution AvailableExtruded pasta tossed with slow-simmered vine tomatoes, cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil, roasted garlic, and fresh sweet basil.
✓ Vegan / Dairy-Free Option • GF Pasta AvailableHomemade Italian meatballs simmered in tomato sauce and finished with creamy whipped ricotta and fresh basil leaves.
✓ Signature Family RecipeToasted bread slices topped with marinated vine tomatoes, fresh basil, and cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil.
✓ Vegetarian • Vegan Option AvailableCrispy zucchini blossoms stuffed with whipped Pecorino Romano and freshly toasted black pepper.
✓ Roman Trattoria SpecialtyCrisp seasonal salads from our quarterly menu served with house-made Italian dressings on the side.
✓ Gluten-Free & Vegan OptionsCrisp pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cream—the signature dessert of Pasta Eater Hell's Kitchen.
✓ VegetarianAsk our team for our current quarterly dessert selections prepared fresh in our 9th Avenue kitchen.
✓ Made In-HousePrepared fresh at 744 9th Ave (between W 50th & W 51st St). Available for express pickup at the trattoria or scheduled delivery within our 2-mile Manhattan radius:
Prefer to discuss your menu and pricing directly with our team? Call us or email us anytime: